A federal judge has ruled the Trump administration violated the First Amendment by pressuring Facebook and Apple to remove ICE-tracking tools. Judge Jorge L. Alonso of the Northern District of Illinois granted a preliminary injunction to two plaintiffs: Kassandra Rosado, who operates the ICE Sightings - Chicagoland Facebook group, and Kreisau Group, developers of the Eyes Up app.
Alonso grounded his ruling in a unanimous 2024 Supreme Court decision, NRA v. Vullo, which established that government actors cannot coerce private platforms into suppressing speech. That precedent is doing real work here, and the reasoning behind how Alonso applied it to executive branch conduct toward Big Tech is what makes the full ruling worth reading.
The injunction is preliminary, not final. What comes next is whether this case sets a durable limit on the administration's ability to jawbone platforms into compliance. The legal mechanism, government coercion as First Amendment violation, is now being tested against one of the most politically charged enforcement contexts in the country.
[READ ORIGINAL →]